Misunderstood

Apple (iPhone 5s)2013

Misunderstood is a 2013 90-second holiday television commercial for Apple, created by TBWA\Media Arts Lab, Los Angeles.

Happy HolidaysApple (iPhone 5s)

Why it works

A teenage boy spends a snowy family Christmas apparently absorbed in his iPhone 5s, on the edge of every snowball fight and tree-decorating session, until Christmas morning, when he plays the family a film of the holiday that he has been shooting and editing all along. Apple released the 90-second ad on 16 December 2013, set to “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas”. TBWA\Media Arts Lab created it and Lance Acord of Park Pictures directed. It was filmed in Edmonton with the extended family of the Calgary actor Chris Ippolito, who told The Globe and Mail that only the teenager was not a relative and that the family’s tears at the screening were real. Reviews split, with a Forbes writer calling it depressing and Advertising Age saying Apple was regaining its creative stride, but in August 2014 it won the Creative Arts Emmy for Outstanding Commercial, ahead of two Budweiser spots, Nike and GE. It was Apple’s second Emmy for an ad, after “The Crazy Ones” in 1998. It is studied for its misdirection, which uses viewers’ assumptions about teenagers and phones to set up the reveal, and for selling a camera without quoting a single specification.

Techniques

  • Storytelling The first half sets the boy up as the family’s problem; the reveal turns him into the person who saved their Christmas.
  • Demonstration The boy’s finished film shows what the iPhone 5s camera and editing can do, with no specifications on screen.

Sources · 4

  1. Apple Launches New Holiday-Themed ‘Misunderstood’ iPhone 5s Commercial MacRumors (2013) · macrumors.com
  2. Apple’s “Misunderstood” Wins Primetime Commercial Emmy Award SHOOTonline (2014) · shootonline.com
  3. Feel-good Apple ad starring Alberta family nabs Emmy award The Globe and Mail (2014) · theglobeandmail.com
  4. Apple’s “Misunderstood” Ad Gets Some Recognition From The Emmy Awards Fast Company (2014) · fastcompany.com

Updated