Keep Mum – She's Not So Dumb!

Ministry of Information (UK)1941

Keep Mum – She's Not So Dumb! is a 1941 careless-talk poster (lithograph) for Ministry of Information, created by Greycaine Ltd, Watford and London.

British careless-talk poster 'Keep mum – she's not so dumb!': a glamorous blonde woman reclines in a chair looking out at the viewer while officers of the Army, Navy and RAF gather round her See the original
Imperial War Museums, via Wikimedia Commons — public domain

The line

Keep mum – she's not so dumb! Careless talk costs lives

Why it works

A glamorous blonde woman in an evening dress reclines in a chair and looks straight out of the poster, while three entranced officers from the Army, Navy and Royal Air Force gather round her, above the rhyme “Keep mum – she's not so dumb!” and the slogan “Careless talk costs lives.” The Ministry of Information produced it in 1941 for its campaign against careless talk, and it was printed for H.M. Stationery Office by Greycaine Ltd. The Imperial War Museums and The National Archives attribute it to Harold Forster, an artist known for his pre-war illustrations on Black Magic chocolate boxes. The National Archives says it was designed to warn service personnel against revealing military information around civilians they did not know, particularly attractive women. The IWM calls it typical of British attempts to instil caution through humorous, memorable slogans rather than frightening images of spies, and adds that the line now seems chauvinistic; the Victoria and Albert Museum notes that it relies on the stereotype of the glamorous female spy, her dress, pose and gaze all implying moral laxity. It is studied as a careless-talk poster aimed at officers rather than the public, and for what it shows about wartime attitudes to women.

Techniques

  • Humour A rhyming, light-hearted line makes the warning memorable without frightening anyone.
  • Storytelling The scene implies its own plot: officers showing off to a woman they assume is harmless, and the secrets that follow.

Sources · 4

  1. Keep Mum - She's Not so Dumb! - Careless Talk Costs Lives (Art.IWM PST 3363) Imperial War Museums · iwm.org.uk
  2. Second World War propaganda posters The National Archives (UK) · nationalarchives.gov.uk
  3. Keep mum, she's not so dumb! Victoria and Albert Museum · collections.vam.ac.uk
  4. Keep Mum - She's Not so Dumb! - Careless Talk Costs Lives (Art.IWM PST 4095) Imperial War Museums · iwm.org.uk

Updated