Who's Absent? Is It You?

Parliamentary Recruiting Committee1915

Who's Absent? Is It You? is a 1915 recruitment poster (colour lithograph) for Parliamentary Recruiting Committee, created by Andrew Reid & Co. Ltd, Newcastle upon Tyne.

PRC poster no. 125: John Bull in a top hat and Union Flag waistcoat points at the viewer, with a row of soldiers with gaps in it behind him and burning buildings in the background; text 'Who's absent? Is it you?' See the original
Library of Congress, via Wikimedia Commons — public domain

The line

Who's absent? Is it you?

Why it works

A British recruiting poster of 1915 in which John Bull, the stout national figure in a top hat and Union Flag waistcoat, points straight at the viewer and asks 'Who's absent? Is it you?', while behind him stands a line of soldiers with gaps in it and buildings burn in the distance. The Parliamentary Recruiting Committee published it as poster no. 125, printed by Andrew Reid and Company of Newcastle upon Tyne in September 1915, according to the National Army Museum. The museum reads the pointing figure as an echo of Alfred Leete's Lord Kitchener and notes that several PRC posters left spaces in the ranks to be filled. Unusually, it says, some of these soldiers look as if they have come straight from combat, one of them hatless, in a rare allusion to the fighting itself. John Bull had personified British, and especially English, values since the 18th century, and the Imperial War Museums observes that apart from the flag waistcoat his dress follows the rules for a gentleman's day clothes set by the Regency dandy Beau Brummell. It is studied as a direct-address poster: the accusing finger and the empty place in the line make the reader the missing man.

Techniques

  • Transfer John Bull, the familiar symbol of Britain, delivers the question, so the nation itself seems to be asking.
  • Pathos The accusing finger and the gap in the ranks are designed to make the reader feel guilty for staying at home.

Sources · 2

  1. 'Who's Absent? Is it you?', recruiting poster, 1915 National Army Museum · collection.nam.ac.uk
  2. Who's Absent? (Art.IWM PST 0314) Imperial War Museums · iwm.org.uk

Updated