Wanted! For Murder: Her Careless Talk Costs Lives

U.S. Army Service Forces (distributed by the Office of War Information)1944

Wanted! For Murder: Her Careless Talk Costs Lives is a 1944 security poster (offset lithograph with photograph) for U.S. Army Service Forces, created by U.S. Government Printing Office.

Victor Keppler's 1944 poster 'Wanted! For murder': a black-and-white photograph of a young woman with styled hair and earrings, framed like a wanted notice, with the line 'Her careless talk costs lives' See the original
U.S. National Archives, via Wikimedia Commons — public domain

The line

Wanted! For murder. Her careless talk costs lives

Why it works

Laid out like a police wanted notice, the poster shows a black-and-white head-and-shoulders photograph of a well-groomed young woman, earrings on and hair neatly styled, under “Wanted!” and above “For murder – Her careless talk costs lives.” The photographer Victor Keppler made the picture. The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum records that the poster was issued in 1944 by the Army Service Forces as part of an “Avoid Careless Talk” series and distributed by the Office of War Information; text printed on the back of mailed copies said it got its “punch” from its likeness to the traditional criminal-apprehension notice, and praised the care taken in choosing the model and her expression. Not everyone admired it. The National Archives quotes a letter to the OWI from a resident of Hawaii complaining that American women knitting, rolling bandages and working long hours resented accusations drawn from “the time-worn gags of newspaper funny men”. It is studied for borrowing a familiar format to turn an ordinary woman into a suspect, and for the gender stereotyping that some viewers objected to at the time.

Techniques

  • Fear appeal Calling a gossip a murderer makes the cost of a careless remark as grave as it can be.
  • Visual metaphor The wanted-poster layout does the arguing, recasting an ordinary young woman as a criminal at large.

Sources · 4

  1. US careless talk poster with a mugshot of a woman wanted for putting lives at risk United States Holocaust Memorial Museum · collections.ushmm.org
  2. Powers of Persuasion: He's Watching You U.S. National Archives · archives.gov
  3. "WANTED FOR MURDER - HER CARELESS TALK COSTS LIVES" (catalogue record) U.S. National Archives · catalog.archives.gov
  4. Poster - Wanted! For Murder Detroit Historical Society · detroithistorical.org

Updated