Technique
Fear appeal
A fear appeal shows people a threat to their health, safety, money or standing, then offers a way to avoid it. These are the most studied fear ads, from Listerine to the CDC, and what research says makes them work or backfire.
What is a fear appeal?
A fear appeal is an ad that shows people a threat, to their health, safety, money, relationships or standing, and then offers a way to avoid it: buy this, stop doing that, vote this way. It is the standard tool of public-health and road-safety campaigns and of political attack ads, and brands use it too, from social embarrassment to identity theft. The research is clear on one point: the threat works best when the ad also makes the way out feel achievable.
Where it comes from
Commercial advertisers used fear first. In 1919 the J. Walter Thompson copywriter James Webb Young revived Odorono deodorant by warning that a woman could offend without ever knowing it (Within the Curve of a Woman's Arm). In the 1920s Listerine turned the clinical-sounding word "halitosis" into a social danger (Often a Bridesmaid but Never a Bride). In the Second World War governments aimed the method at whole populations, with posters warning that one careless remark could drown a sailor (Someone Talked!).
The first well-known experiment came in 1953, when Irving Janis and Seymour Feshbach gave high-school students lectures on dental hygiene at different levels of fear. They concluded that a strong fear appeal tends to make a message less effective if it creates a lot of tension without enough reassurance. Howard Leventhal's 1970 framework separated controlling a danger from controlling one's own fear, and in 1992 Kim Witte combined it with work by Janis and Ronald Rogers in the Extended Parallel Process Model (EPPM).
The EPPM says people make two judgements. First, is the threat serious, and is it likely to affect me? Second, does the recommended action work, and can I do it (efficacy)? When both are high, people act to control the danger. When the threat is high but efficacy is low, they control their fear instead, by denying the risk, avoiding the message or reacting against it.
How to spot it
- A vivid consequence, shown rather than described: a crash, a disease, a lost job, a lonely life.
- Personal language or casting that says this could happen to you or someone you love.
- A clear action that removes the threat, often in the last seconds.
- Urgency: a countdown, a deadline, a moment frozen before disaster.
The best examples
- Daisy (Lyndon B. Johnson campaign, 1964). A girl counting petals dissolves into a nuclear countdown. It ran once as a paid spot, never named the opponent, and the news replayed it in full.
- Don't Die of Ignorance (UK Government, 1986). An exploding cliff face and a granite tombstone on television, with a leaflet sent to every household. The fear pointed to one action: read the leaflet.
- This Is Your Brain on Drugs (Partnership for a Drug-Free America, 1987). An egg frying in a pan, in ten seconds. It became the most remembered public service ad of the 1980s, and a standard target for researchers who saw it as fear-based oversimplification.
- Girlfriend (TAC Victoria, 1989). Filmed in a working emergency ward to "upset, outrage and appal" drink drivers, it launched alongside expanded random breath testing. The fear came with visible enforcement.
- Tips From Former Smokers (CDC, 2012). Former smokers show what disease has done to them, and the ads give a quitline number. A study in The Lancet estimated 1.6 million extra quit attempts from the first 12-week run.
- Mistakes (NZ Transport Agency, 2014). Time freezes before a crash while the two drivers talk. It accepts that viewers think they drive well and makes the threat other people's errors, so slowing down feels like a reasonable answer.
- Back-to-School Essentials (Sandy Hook Promise, 2019). A cheerful shopping video turns into a school shooting, then names a specific action: learn the warning signs.
Why it works, and when it backfires
Fear appeals work more often than their critics claim. A 2015 meta-analysis in Psychological Bulletin by Melanie Tannenbaum, Dolores Albarracín and colleagues pooled 248 samples covering 27,372 people and found a positive effect on attitudes, intentions and behaviour. The effect was larger when the message included efficacy statements, showed both high severity and high susceptibility, and asked for a one-off action rather than a repeated one. The authors found no circumstances in which fear appeals backfired. Witte and Mike Allen's 2000 meta-analysis agreed that strong fear combined with strong efficacy produces the most change, but found that strong fear with weak efficacy produced the most defensive reactions.
Real campaigns show what defensive reactions look like. Australia's Grim Reaper (1987) pushed AIDS onto front pages but was pulled after three weeks, and the doctor who had diagnosed the country's first case later said viewers came to associate the Reaper with gay men, deepening stigma. The Montana Meth Project showed peers ruined by the drug in graphic detail; its backers cited falling use, but a 2010 study in the Journal of Health Economics found effects on use statistically indistinguishable from zero once an existing downward trend was accounted for. The lesson from the research and the campaigns is the same: give frightened people something they can do. See also negativity bias and loss aversion.
Fear vs shock
Fear and shock often appear in the same ad, but they work differently. A fear appeal is about a threat to the viewer and a way to escape it; its power comes from the consequence. Shock is about a broken norm, an image or words that violate what advertising is expected to show, used to startle people into attention. In 2003 Darren Dahl, Kristina Frankenberger and Rajesh Manchanda defined shock as a combination of norm violation and surprise, and tested a shocking HIV-prevention poster against a fear poster and an information poster with university students. The shocking poster won on attention and recall. On behaviour, the shock and fear posters did about equally well: around half the students in each group picked up HIV information afterwards, against about a fifth of those who saw the information poster or none.
Many of the most studied public-health films use both: the TAC's emergency ward is frightening because it could be you, and shocking in its graphic detail. For ads built mainly on provocation, see shock advertising.
Every ad here that uses fear appeal34
2020s
2010s
-
2019Back-to-School Essentials
Confronts parents with the threat of a shooting at school, then offers a concrete way to help prevent it: learning the warning signs.
-
2014Mistakes
Freezes two cars moments before a collision to show that driving a little too fast leaves no room for other people's mistakes, so slow down.
-
2014Eyes on the Road
As viewers look down, the on-screen car crashes, followed by the claim that phone use is the leading cause of death at the wheel.
-
2012Tips From Former Smokers ("Terrie")
It shows the lasting physical damage of smoking-related disease to frighten smokers into calling a quitline and trying to quit.
2000s
-
2005Not Even Once ("Just Once")
Graphic scenes of peers ruined by the drug warn that trying meth even once leads to stealing, sex for drugs and a sister following suit.
-
2003Outfit (Identity Theft)
Makes the invisible threat of identity theft vivid by putting a thief's gloating voice in a victim's mouth, then offers the bank's new service as protection.
1990s
1980s
-
1989Girlfriend ("If You Drink, Then Drive, You're a Bloody Idiot")
It confronts drink drivers with the injuries they could inflict on someone close to them, reinforced by an expansion of random breath testing.
-
"I never read The Economist." Management trainee. Aged 42.The Economist1988
"I never read The Economist." Management trainee. Aged 42.
The confession of a 42-year-old management trainee warns readers of the career cost of not reading the magazine.
-
1987The Grim Reaper
A hooded Death bowls down men, women and children as pins, warning that the disease is no longer confined to any one group.
-
1987This Is Your Brain on Drugs ("Fried Egg")
Equates drug use with a brain frying like an egg in a hot pan, a blunt threat to health delivered in seconds.
-
1986Don't Die of Ignorance ("Monolith")
A granite tombstone carved with the disease's name and a funereal voiceover warn that ignoring it could be the death of you.
1970s
1960s
1940s
-
1944Wanted! For Murder: Her Careless Talk Costs Lives
Calling a gossip a murderer makes the cost of a careless remark as grave as it can be.
-
1943When You Ride Alone You Ride with Hitler!
Equating a half-empty car with collaboration makes wasting scarce fuel and tyres feel like helping the enemy win.
-
1942Don't Let That Shadow Touch Them
The swastika appears only as a shadow creeping towards children at play, a threat that has not yet struck.
-
1942He's Coming South
An enemy soldier about to stamp on the map of Australia presents invasion as imminent and personal.
-
1942He's Watching You
A helmeted enemy watching from just behind the lettering puts a spy within earshot of every factory-floor conversation.
-
1942Loose Lips Might Sink Ships
A ship rolling over into black smoke shows the deadly result of a careless word, warning the viewer to stay silent.
-
1942Someone Talked!
A drowning sailor points at the viewer, making the deadly consequence of a careless remark personal and immediate.
-
1942This Is Nazi Brutality
The National Archives notes the implied message that what happened in Lidice could happen in America.
-
Careless talk costs livesMinistry of Information (UK)1940
Careless Talk Costs Lives
Beneath the joke, the blunt claim that careless talk costs lives reminds readers what is at stake if they chatter.
1930s
1920s
1910s
-
1919Within the Curve of a Woman's Arm
Lyrical copy warns that a woman could offend without ever knowing it, turning sweat into a hidden social danger the product removes.
-
1918?
Blood spreading from Europe across the globe suggests the danger will reach Australia too.
-
1918Beat Back the Hun with Liberty Bonds
A blood-soaked soldier among smouldering ruins gazes across the ocean towards America, playing on fears of a German invasion.
-
1918Destroy This Mad Brute – Enlist
A bloodied club and a captive woman on America's own shore make invasion feel close at hand, with enlistment offered as the only defence.
-
1918Remember Belgium – Buy Bonds – Fourth Liberty Loan
The spiked-helmet silhouette and the flames show what German victory is supposed to look like.
-
1918That Liberty Shall Not Perish from the Earth
Shows New York in flames and Liberty beheaded, so the reader pictures the war arriving at home unless bonds are bought.
-
1915Is Your Home Worth Fighting For?
Shows enemy soldiers at the family's own door, making invasion feel personal and close.
-
1914Remember Belgium – Enlist To-day
The burning village in the background shows what German invasion has already done to a neighbour.
Questions people ask
What is a fear appeal in advertising?
A fear appeal is an ad that shows a threat, such as illness, injury, financial loss or embarrassment, and then offers a way to avoid it. It is common in public-health, road-safety and political advertising, and for products sold as protection.
Do fear appeals work?
Generally, yes. A 2015 meta-analysis of 248 samples covering more than 27,000 people found that fear appeals had a positive effect on attitudes, intentions and behaviour, and worked best when they told people what to do and the action was a one-off.
What is the Extended Parallel Process Model?
The Extended Parallel Process Model (EPPM), proposed by Kim Witte in 1992, says people respond to a fear appeal by judging the threat and their ability to act on it. High threat with high efficacy leads them to control the danger; high threat with low efficacy leads them to control their fear through denial or avoidance.
What are examples of fear appeal ads?
Well-known examples include Listerine's halitosis ads of the 1920s, Lyndon Johnson's "Daisy" (1964), the UK's "Don't Die of Ignorance" AIDS campaign (1986), "This Is Your Brain on Drugs" (1987) and the CDC's "Tips From Former Smokers" (2012).
When do fear appeals backfire?
Fear appeals are most likely to fail when the threat is strong but the audience doubts it can do anything about it. Witte and Allen's 2000 meta-analysis found that this combination produced the most defensive responses, such as avoidance and reactance.
What is the difference between fear and shock advertising?
Fear advertising threatens the viewer with a consequence and offers a way out. Shock advertising breaks a social norm to surprise people into attention, and need not threaten the viewer at all.
Sources5
- Effects of fear-arousing communications
- Putting the fear back into fear appeals: The extended parallel process model
- A meta-analysis of fear appeals: implications for effective public health campaigns
- Appealing to fear: A Meta-Analysis of Fear Appeal Effectiveness and Theories
- Does It Pay to Shock? Reactions to Shocking and Nonshocking Advertising Content among University Students


