Within the Curve of a Woman's Arm

Odorono1919

Within the Curve of a Woman's Arm is a 1919 magazine advertisement for Odorono, created by J. Walter Thompson.

The 1919 Odorono advertisement "Within the Curve of a Woman's Arm": an illustration of a couple about to embrace above the headline, the subhead "A frank discussion of a subject too often avoided" and three columns of copy, from Vanity Fair, May 1919 See the original
Vanity Fair, May 1919, via Internet Archive — public domain

The line

Within the curve of a woman's arm

Why it works

The ad that taught American women to worry about sweat. Odorono, an antiperspirant first sold by a Cincinnati schoolgirl, had stalled by 1919, and a J. Walter Thompson door-to-door survey showed why: every woman knew it, but two-thirds felt they had no need for it. Copywriter James Webb Young stopped selling a remedy and started selling a social danger. Beneath a picture of a couple about to embrace, his headline opened into lyrical long copy warning that a woman could offend without ever knowing it. Some 200 Ladies' Home Journal readers cancelled their subscriptions and women Young knew stopped speaking to him, but Odorono's sales rose 112 per cent to $417,000 the next year, according to JWT's archives, and reached $1 million by 1927. It is studied as the prototype of "whisper copy", the insinuating, anxiety-led style that rivals soon imitated, and as an early case of research redirecting creative strategy. Young was later inducted into the One Club's Creative Hall of Fame.

Techniques

  • Fear appeal Lyrical copy warns that a woman could offend without ever knowing it, turning sweat into a hidden social danger the product removes.

Sources · 3

  1. How Advertisers Convinced Americans They Smelled Bad Smithsonian Magazine (2012) · smithsonianmag.com
  2. Odor, Oh No! Advertising Deodorant and the New Science of Psychology, 1910 to 1925 Juliann Sivulka, Proceedings of the Conference on Historical Analysis and Research in Marketing (CHARM) (2007) · ojs.library.carleton.ca
  3. James Webb Young The One Club Creative Hall of Fame · creativehalloffame.org

Updated