Destroy This Mad Brute – Enlist

U.S. Army1918

Destroy This Mad Brute – Enlist is a 1918 recruitment poster (colour lithograph) for U.S. Army.

Harry R. Hopps's US Army recruiting poster: a snarling gorilla in a spiked helmet marked “Militarism” steps ashore clutching a bloodied club marked “Kultur” and a half-naked woman, above the words “Destroy this mad brute” and “Enlist – U.S. Army” See the original
Library of Congress, via Wikimedia Commons — public domain

The line

Destroy this mad brute – Enlist

Why it works

A gorilla in a spiked helmet marked “Militarism” steps onto the shore of America with a bloodied club labelled “Kultur” in one hand and a half-naked woman in the other arm, a ruined Europe behind it, above the order “Destroy this mad brute – Enlist”. Harry R. Hopps drew it for the US Army. The Library of Congress records that the San Francisco Army Recruiting District registered it for copyright on 4 April 1918, although the Met and other collections date it to 1917. The poster never names Germany: the German word on the club does that, along with a moustache the Met likens to Kaiser Wilhelm II's. The Met reads the captive as Lady Liberty, while The New Criterion sees an allusion to the invasion of Belgium in 1914. In place of an argument for war, it offers one label, a mad brute, and makes the viewer the only defence against it. It greeted visitors at the entrance to the Met's 2017 exhibition World War I and the Visual Arts, and Johns Hopkins University's libraries note that anti-German themes like this one fed the discrimination German-Americans faced during the war. It is studied as one of the starkest cases of name-calling in recruitment advertising, and for an ape the Met calls a precursor of King Kong.

Techniques

  • Name-calling Never names Germany but brands it a “mad brute”, drawn as a slavering ape, so enlisting becomes a reply to a monster rather than to an argument about the war.
  • Fear appeal A bloodied club and a captive woman on America's own shore make invasion feel close at hand, with enlistment offered as the only defence.
  • Visual metaphor The words on the helmet and club, “Militarism” and “Kultur”, turn the gorilla into a walking caricature of the enemy nation.

Sources · 4

  1. Destroy this mad brute Enlist - U.S. Army. (catalogue record) Library of Congress · loc.gov
  2. Humor and Horror: Printed Propaganda during World War I The Metropolitan Museum of Art (2017) · metmuseum.org
  3. Exhibition note: “World War I and the Visual Arts” at the Metropolitan Museum of Art The New Criterion (2017) · newcriterion.com
  4. Destroy This Mad Brute - Enlist - US Army Johns Hopkins Sheridan Libraries and Museums · exhibits.library.jhu.edu

Updated