Technique
Card stacking
Card stacking is a propaganda technique that builds a one-sided case: favourable facts are played up, awkward ones left out, and half-truths presented as the whole truth, so only one conclusion seems possible.
What is card stacking?
Card stacking is a propaganda technique that arranges the evidence so that only one conclusion seems possible: favourable facts are emphasised, unfavourable ones are left out, and half-truths stand in for the whole truth. The name comes from a cheat's stacked deck: every card may be real, but the order has been fixed before the game begins.
Card stacking can be built entirely from true statements. What makes it propaganda is the selection: the case is assembled to win, not to inform. It is also the hardest of the seven devices to catch, because you can only judge the cards you are shown.
Where the term comes from
Card stacking is the sixth of the seven propaganda devices listed by the Institute for Propaganda Analysis (IPA) in 1937, and its bulletin described it at length. The propagandist "stacks the cards against the truth", it said. "He uses under-emphasis and over-emphasis to dodge issues and evade facts. He resorts to lies, censorship, and distortion. He omits facts. He offers false testimony." He raises a new issue when he wants an embarrassing one forgotten, draws "a 'red herring' across the trail", and "lets half-truth masquerade as truth". The bulletin concluded that card stacking "is hardest to detect, because it is adroitly executed or because we lack the information necessary to nail the lie".
The Fine Art of Propaganda (1939) defined it as "the selection and use of facts or falsehoods, illustrations or distractions, and logical or illogical statements in order to give the best or the worst possible case for an idea, program, person or product". The book accepted that every advocate stacks the cards for their own side, as local speakers around the traditional "cracker barrel" each make their best case. What it warned against was "monopolistic" card stacking: hearing only one side. Its symbol was the ace of spades, "a card traditionally used to signify treachery".
How to spot it
- Numbers without a base: "80% recommend", "up to 50% off", "twice as effective". Of what, and compared with what?
- Only good news, with no costs, side effects, conditions or rival evidence.
- Small print that quietly contradicts the headline.
- One vivid case presented as typical.
- A "survey" whose questions, sample or sponsor you are not told.
- A sudden new controversy that changes the subject.
- A weakness reframed as a strength, with the drawback itself never examined.
Examples
"More than 80% of dentists" (2007)
In 2007 the UK's Advertising Standards Authority ruled that Colgate's poster claim "More than 80% of dentists recommend Colgate" was misleading. The dentists surveyed had been allowed to name more than one brand, and a rival brand was recommended almost as often. The figure came from a real survey; the impression it gave, that four in five dentists preferred Colgate to every other toothpaste, did not.
The doctors' survey (1946)
Camel's long-running claim that "More doctors smoke Camels than any other cigarette" rested on surveys that, according to a 2006 study in the American Journal of Public Health, were carried out by the company's own advertising agency, mostly just after the doctors had been handed free cartons of Camels. A testimonial was built on a stacked deck.
A witness without a name (1990)
In October 1990 a 15-year-old girl identified only as "Nayirah" told the Congressional Human Rights Caucus that Iraqi soldiers in Kuwait had taken scores of babies from incubators and left them to die. Her testimony, The New York Times later wrote, helped build support for the Gulf War. In January 1992 it emerged that she was the daughter of Kuwait's ambassador to the United States, a fact withheld at the hearing, and doubts were raised about her account.
In this directory
- Hoover's Free Flights Promotion (1992) headlined two free return flights for £100 spent on its products, while tight deadlines, unwanted dates and costly extras sat in the background.
- Folha de S.Paulo's "Hitler" (1987) lists a leader's real achievements as dots build up his face, then reveals Hitler: a demonstration that you can tell a pack of lies using only the truth.
- Think Small (1959), We Try Harder (1963) and Reassuringly Expensive (1982) show the device at its most honest: each admits a drawback and plays up the side of it that helps the brand.
Why it works, and where it fails
A confident one-sided case is easy to follow and hard to rebut on the spot. Most of us do not have the missing information to hand, and numbers look objective even when the question behind them was rigged. Card stacking also flatters the audience: it feels like being given the facts, not being sold to.
It fails when the missing card turns up. A regulator asks for the survey, as with Colgate; a journalist checks who a witness really is; customers discover the conditions behind a free offer. Then the whole case collapses, and the trust goes with it, because people feel tricked rather than merely persuaded.
Card stacking vs lying
People often ask whether card stacking is just lying. Not exactly. A lie is a false statement. Card stacking is a way of arranging statements, true or false, so that the overall impression is false. The IPA included lies within the device, but its most effective form uses true facts chosen and ordered to mislead: the Colgate figure was real, and the Folha film uses only true statements. Logicians call the same move "suppressed evidence" or "cherry-picking".
Card stacking vs testimonial
Many stacked cases use a testimonial as one of the cards, as with Camel's doctors and Nayirah. When you see a witness or an expert, ask who chose them and who was left out. See testimonial.
How to answer it
Ask what is missing. Who ran the survey, what exactly was asked, and who was counted? What are the conditions, the costs, the side effects? What would the strongest opponent put on the table? Because the danger, in the IPA's words, is the "monopolistic" case, the cure is to hear the other side before deciding. Suspend judgement until you have seen at least one source that does not come from the person making the claim, and treat any single striking number as the start of a question, not the end of one.
Every ad here that uses card stacking16
-
2017Black Supermarket (Le Marché Interdit)
Frames legal vegetables as forbidden goods, leaving out that only the seeds are restricted, to make a dry regulatory dispute feel like an outlaw story.
-
2014Inglorious Fruits & Vegetables
Turns the produce's weakness into a selling point, giving rejects their own proud branding and a price about 30% lower.
-
2011Born of Fire ("Imported from Detroit")
Turns the brand's biggest liabilities, a written-off city, bailouts and decline, into its whole argument for luxury that has been to hell and back.
-
He's the biggest celebrity in the world. But is he ready to lead?John McCain presidential campaign2008
Celeb
Follows the label with a one-sided list, no to offshore drilling and taxes on electricity, ending “Higher taxes. More foreign oil. That's the real Obama.”
-
2007No Money, but Love (Yubari Fusai)
Owns the city's bankruptcy instead of hiding it, recasting a lack of money as an abundance of love and promoting its low divorce rate.
-
2004Grrr ("Hate Something, Change Something")
Leads with diesel's most hated qualities, turning an engineer's loathing of noisy old engines into the case for Honda's better one.
-
1999Surfer
Recasts the long wait for a properly settled pint, an operational drawback, as the patient virtue that defines the whole brand.
-
1992Free Flights Promotion
Headlines only the generous offer while relying on tight deadlines, unwanted dates and costly extras to deter people from claiming.
-
1984Lalitaji
Defends the higher price instead of cutting it, recasting the gap with a much cheaper rival as proof of better value.
-
Reassuringly expensive.Stella Artois1982
Reassuringly Expensive
Two words recast a premium price, usually a drawback, as reassuring proof of quality.
-
1971Because I'm Worth It
Turns the higher price into a virtue, since she pays more precisely because she is worth it.
-
1966The Disadvantages
Cheerfully lists the awkward disadvantages of an extra-long cigarette, so each supposed flaw quietly advertises the extra length and extra puffs.
-
Avis is only No. 2 in rent a cars. So we try harder.Avis1963
We Try Harder ("Avis is only No. 2")
Admitting it is only number two becomes the reason to choose the company, because it has to try harder.
-
1959Think Small
Calling the car small and even a lemon turns its apparent weaknesses into reasons to trust and buy it.
-
More doctors smoke Camels than any other cigarette.Camel (R.J. Reynolds Tobacco)1946
More Doctors Smoke Camels
Cites a survey of 113,597 doctors without saying that the brand's own agency ran it, often just after handing out free cartons.
-
1917Das ist der Weg zum Frieden
'The enemy wants it so' puts all the blame for the war's continuation on the other side and leaves out any talk of terms.
Questions people ask
What is card stacking in propaganda?
Card stacking is a propaganda technique that builds a one-sided case by emphasising favourable facts, leaving out unfavourable ones and presenting half-truths as the whole truth. It is one of the seven propaganda devices listed by the Institute for Propaganda Analysis in 1937.
What is an example of card stacking?
In 2007 the UK Advertising Standards Authority ruled that Colgate's claim "More than 80% of dentists recommend Colgate" was misleading, because the dentists surveyed could name several brands and a rival was recommended almost as often. The number was real, but the impression it created was not.
Is card stacking the same as lying?
Not quite. A lie is a false statement, while card stacking arranges statements, often true ones, so that the overall impression is false. The Institute for Propaganda Analysis included lies in the device, but much card stacking uses only selected truths.
Is card stacking a logical fallacy?
Yes. Logicians call it the fallacy of suppressed evidence, also known as cherry-picking or stacking the deck: presenting only the evidence that supports a conclusion while hiding what weighs against it.
Why is card stacking hard to detect?
Because you can only judge the evidence you are shown. The Institute for Propaganda Analysis wrote in 1937 that card stacking "is hardest to detect, because it is adroitly executed or because we lack the information necessary to nail the lie".
What is the difference between card stacking and cherry-picking?
They describe the same move. Cherry-picking is the logician's term for selecting only favourable evidence; card stacking is the propaganda term, and it also covers distractions, red herrings and outright falsehoods used to build a one-sided case.
Where does the name card stacking come from?
From cheating at cards by secretly arranging the deck. The Institute for Propaganda Analysis gave the device the symbol of an ace of spades, a card traditionally used to signify treachery.
Sources8
- Propaganda Analysis, Volume I (includes “How to Detect Propaganda”, the bulletin’s second issue, 1937)
- The Fine Art of Propaganda (excerpts from the Institute for Propaganda Analysis book, ed. Alfred McClung Lee and Elizabeth Briant Lee, 1939)
- The Iconography of Propaganda Analysis (excerpts from The Fine Art of Propaganda, 1939)
- Colgate warned over '80%' boast
- “The Doctors’ Choice Is America’s Choice”: The Physician in US Cigarette Advertisements, 1930–1953
- Doubts Cast on Girl's Account of Iraqi Atrocities in Kuwait
- Deception on Capitol Hill
- Fallacies