Technique
Bandwagon
Bandwagon is a propaganda technique that urges people to join in because everyone else already has: crowds, popularity claims and the fear of being left out stand in for reasons.
What is bandwagon propaganda?
Bandwagon is a propaganda technique that persuades people to accept an idea, buy a product or back a candidate because everyone else, or everyone like them, is already doing so. Its message is "join us": the size of the crowd is offered as the reason. In advertising it appears as popularity claims ("the world's favourite", "millions sold", "the nation's number one"), crowds, rankings, sales counters, trends and the fear of missing out.
Popularity is not always irrelevant. If many people have tried something and judged it good, that is some evidence in its favour. Bandwagon becomes propaganda when the crowd is the whole argument, when the crowd has been staged, or when it is smaller than it is made to look.
Where the term comes from
Band wagon is the last of the seven propaganda devices listed by the Institute for Propaganda Analysis (IPA) in 1937. Its bulletin gave the theme as "Everybody's doing it", and described how the propagandist "hires a hall, fills a great stadium, marches a million men in parade" and "employs symbols, colors, music, movement, all the dramatic arts". He appeals to people as members of a group: "as Catholics, Protestants or Jews", "as farmers or as school teachers; as housewives or as miners". Its election example still sounds familiar: "Don't throw your vote away. Vote for our candidate. He's sure to win."
The Fine Art of Propaganda (1939) put the theme as "Everybody—at least all of us—is doing it", and chose as its symbol a bandmaster's hat and baton, "such as were once used on old-fashioned band wagons", the wagons that carried a band at the head of a parade. It added a dry reminder: "there is never as much of a rush to climb onto the Band Wagon as the propagandist tries to make us think there is."
How to spot it
- Popularity offered as proof: "best-selling", "most popular", "the world's favourite", "join millions".
- Crowds, queues, packed stadiums and mass rallies.
- Counters and league tables: sales totals, follower counts, ratings, "trending".
- Deadlines and countdowns that suggest everyone else is acting now.
- Appeals to your group: "every real fan", "true patriots", "women of Britain".
- Ask: how many people, counted by whom, and does their choice tell me anything about mine?
Examples
A rally on film (1934)
Leni Riefenstahl's Triumph of the Will, filmed at the 1934 Nazi Party rally in Nuremberg, presents Germans massed in apparent unanimity behind Hitler. In one scene a roll-call of 52,000 labour men ends in the chant "One people, one leader, one realm—Germany!" The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum notes that several scenes were carefully staged and some speeches were delivered more than once for the cameras: a crowd arranged to look like a nation.
Women of Britain Say "Go!" (1915)
The recruiting poster Women of Britain Say – 'Go!' speaks for all the women of Britain at once, implying a national consensus that the reluctant recruit is defying.
The world's favourite airline (1989)
In British Airways' Face, thousands of people assemble into a single smiling face while the voiceover counts the millions the airline brings together, a picture of the claim to be "the world's favourite airline".
Spotify Wrapped (2016 onwards)
Spotify Wrapped turns each listener's year into a shareable summary. When millions post theirs at the same time, taking part feels like something everyone is doing. Singles' Day does the same for shopping, publishing ever-larger sales totals.
Bought followers (2018)
A New York Times investigation in 2018 found that a company called Devumi had sold more than 200 million Twitter followers to customers who wanted to look more popular, drawing on at least 3.5 million automated accounts. A fake crowd is the bandwagon device made to order.
Why it works, and where it fails
People look to others when they are unsure what to do. In Solomon Asch's conformity experiments of 1951, about three-quarters of participants went along at least once with a group that gave an obviously wrong answer about the length of a line. Following the crowd saves effort and brings the comfort of belonging (see social proof and belonging).
It fails when the crowd turns out to be fake or smaller than claimed, and when the audience wants to stand apart. Some brands win by doing the opposite and casting themselves as the underdog, as Avis did by admitting it was only number two (see the underdog effect).
Bandwagon vs glittering generalities
Both feel uplifting, so they are often confused. Bandwagon sells popularity: "everyone is joining". Glittering generalities sell virtue: "this stands for freedom". A slogan like "Join the movement for a better tomorrow" uses both.
Bandwagon vs social proof
Social proof is the psychologist's name for the tendency to copy what others do; bandwagon is the propaganda technique that exploits it. A genuine review count is social proof. A staged crowd, a bought follower count or a claim that "everyone" agrees is bandwagon.
Bandwagon vs plain folks
Plain folks says "I am one of you"; bandwagon says "all of you are doing this". One is about the speaker, the other about the crowd.
Is bandwagon a logical fallacy?
Yes, when popularity is offered as proof. Logicians call it the bandwagon fallacy, a close cousin of the appeal to the people (argumentum ad populum): believing a claim is right simply because many people believe it, or are coming to believe it.
How to answer it
The IPA's questions are still the right ones. What is this propagandist's programme? What is the evidence for and against it? Does it serve or undermine the interests of the group they say is behind them? Then check the crowd. Who counted it, and is it real? Is it people like you, or a number chosen because it is large? Finally, imagine being the first person to decide: if nobody else had chosen it yet, would you?
Every ad here that uses bandwagon11
-
2016Spotify Wrapped
Hundreds of millions of people posting their results at once fill social feeds, making taking part feel like something everyone is doing.
-
Share a Coke with...Coca-Cola2011
Share a Coke
As people hunted for their names and posted the bottles, the search became self-sustaining social content, making a named Coke feel like something everyone was getting.
-
2009Singles' Day (11.11)
Turns one date into a mass shopping event, publishing ever-larger sales totals until rivals end up running their own versions.
-
Windows. Life without walls.Microsoft (Windows)2008
I'm a PC
A procession of PC users from around the world, from scientists to celebrities, each declare “I'm a PC”, presenting Windows as the choice of a billion people.
-
2007Earth Hour
Draws its power from mobilisation, as famous landmarks go dark and the event grows each year across countries and cities.
-
1989Face
Thousands of people assemble into one smiling face while the voiceover counts millions brought together, literally picturing the claim to be the world's favourite.
-
You like Ike, I like Ike, everybody likes Ike – for president.Dwight D. Eisenhower presidential campaign1952
Ike for President
A parade of ordinary Americans marches behind the candidate while the chorus insists “everybody likes Ike” and urges viewers to “get in step”.
-
More doctors smoke Camels than any other cigarette.Camel (R.J. Reynolds Tobacco)1946
More Doctors Smoke Camels
Turns a head count into the argument, more doctors smoke Camels than any other brand, and by 1952 bills the doctors' choice as America's choice.
-
1917Enlist: On Which Side of the Window Are You?
The column is already on the move, so the man at the window is the one being left behind.
-
1915Step Into Your Place
Men from every trade are already marching off to war, and the headline directs the viewer to the end of the queue, so enlisting means simply following everyone else.
-
1915Women of Britain Say – ‘Go!’
The headline speaks for all the women of Britain at once, implying a national consensus that the reluctant recruit is defying.
Questions people ask
What is bandwagon propaganda?
Bandwagon is a propaganda technique that urges people to accept an idea, buy a product or support a candidate because everyone else is already doing so. The Institute for Propaganda Analysis listed it as the seventh of its propaganda devices in 1937, summing it up as "Everybody's doing it".
What is an example of bandwagon advertising?
Claims such as "the world's favourite airline", used by British Airways, or "join millions" are typical. Spotify Wrapped works the same way: when millions of people share their results in the same week, taking part feels like something everyone is doing.
Is bandwagon a logical fallacy?
Yes, when popularity is offered as proof. The bandwagon fallacy, closely related to the appeal to the people (argumentum ad populum), treats a claim as true or a product as good simply because many people believe in it or are buying it.
What is the bandwagon effect?
The bandwagon effect is the tendency to adopt a belief or behaviour because many others have. In Solomon Asch's 1951 conformity experiments, about three-quarters of participants went along at least once with a group's obviously wrong answer.
What is the difference between bandwagon and glittering generalities?
Bandwagon sells popularity ("everyone is joining"), while glittering generalities sell virtue ("this stands for freedom"). Both skip the evidence, and many slogans combine them.
What is the difference between bandwagon and social proof?
Social proof is the psychological tendency to copy what others do; bandwagon is the propaganda technique that exploits it. Genuine reviews are social proof, while staged crowds or bought followers are bandwagon.
Where does the term bandwagon come from?
A bandwagon was the wagon that carried a band in a parade. The Institute for Propaganda Analysis used the image of jumping on the band wagon for following the crowd, and gave the device the symbol of a bandmaster's hat and baton, "such as were once used on old-fashioned band wagons".
Sources8
- Propaganda Analysis, Volume I (includes “How to Detect Propaganda”, the bulletin’s second issue, 1937)
- The Fine Art of Propaganda (excerpts from the Institute for Propaganda Analysis book, ed. Alfred McClung Lee and Elizabeth Briant Lee, 1939)
- The Iconography of Propaganda Analysis (excerpts from The Fine Art of Propaganda, 1939)
- Fallacies
- 1951: Psychologist Solomon Asch's Famous Experiments
- Propaganda Film: Triumph of the Will
- The Follower Factory
- Bandwagon