Technique
Shock and provocation
Shock advertising deliberately breaks a social norm or taboo to startle people into attention and conversation. These are the most controversial ads, from Benetton to Burger King's mouldy Whopper, what the provocation achieved and what it cost.
What is shock advertising?
Shock advertising deliberately breaks a social norm, showing or saying something most ads would avoid, to startle people into paying attention and talking. The provocation can be graphic, sexual, religious, political or simply disgusting. Charities and public-health bodies use it on serious subjects, and fashion and youth brands have used it to make themselves part of an argument. The complaints, bans and press coverage that follow are usually part of the plan.
Where it comes from
Among the earliest provocations still studied is a 1949 campaign in which women dreamed they were out in public in their bras, risqué enough to draw complaints that only spread it further (I Dreamed I Went Shopping in My Maidenform Bra). In 1970 the young London agency Cramer Saatchi showed a heavily pregnant man to persuade men to take contraception seriously (Pregnant Man). In 1973 the Italian photographer Oliviero Toscani shot a model's behind in denim shorts under a line from the Gospels for Jesus Jeans, and the Vatican's newspaper called it blasphemous (Chi mi ama mi segua).
Toscani then made provocation a brand strategy. As Benetton's art director in the 1980s and 1990s he put pictures that would have been unremarkable in a news magazine, from a newborn baby still bloody from birth to prisoners on death row, on billboards and in the prestige ad pages of fashion magazines, often leaving the clothes out entirely (New Born Baby). The Guardian's obituary of Toscani argued that his images provoked not because of what they showed but because of where they were seen. Governments brought the same deliberate disturbance to AIDS campaigns in 1986 and 1987 (Don't Die of Ignorance), and online campaigns have since turned shock into a reveal, as when a French addiction-help website revealed that the admired Instagram influencer it had created was an invented alcoholic.
In 2003 Darren Dahl, Kristina Frankenberger and Rajesh Manchanda gave the technique an academic definition, a combination of norm violation and surprise, and noted that it had been widely used but barely tested.
How to spot it
- An image or word that breaks a taboo about sex, death, religion, violence or disgust.
- A deliberate jolt: the ad starts as one thing and turns into something disturbing.
- Little or no product on show, so the provocation carries the brand.
- Complaints, bans and news coverage that take the ad far beyond its paid media.
The best examples
- Pregnant Man (Health Education Council, 1970). An image many people found shocking, even offensive, was itself the argument: men would be more careful if they were the ones who got pregnant. The V&A and the Science Museum Group hold it.
- New Born Baby (Benetton, 1991). A newborn with the cord uncut and nothing but the logo. It drew 800 complaints to the UK's Advertising Standards Authority and was withdrawn in Britain, yet the V&A added it to its collection.
- Hello Boys (Wonderbra, 1994). Two cheeky words beside a model looking down at her own cleavage. A £150,000 media spend generated an estimated £5 million of free press coverage.
- Unhate (Benetton, 2011). Montages of world leaders kissing their adversaries. The image of the Pope was pulled almost at once, Benetton counted more than 3,000 articles in 60 countries, and the campaign won the Press Grand Prix at Cannes.
- Meet the Superhumans (Channel 4, 2012). Paralympians train, then the film cuts without warning to a car crash, a war zone and a hospital. The jolt replaced pity with respect.
- Like My Addiction (Addict'Aide, 2016). An admired Paris Instagrammer turned out to be an invented alcoholic, with a drink in every post. The reveal shocked followers who had cheered her on without noticing.
- Moldy Whopper (Burger King, 2020). The flagship burger shown furred with mould over 35 days. Making the product look disgusting proved it had no artificial preservatives, and the agencies reported a 14% sales lift.
Why it works, and when it backfires
Shock buys attention. In Dahl and colleagues' first experiment, 84% of the students who saw a shocking HIV-prevention poster picked it as the poster that drew their attention most, against 41% for a fear poster and 47% for an information poster, and 97% recalled it, against 78% for each of the others. Most of those who picked the shocking poster mentioned the norm it broke. The researchers noted the limits: memory was tested after a short delay, and whether shock wears out faster than other appeals was left untested.
The costs are real. Shock can trivialise its subject or stigmatise the people it shows: the doctor who had diagnosed Australia's first AIDS case later said the Grim Reaper deepened stigma against gay men. Regulators can end a campaign: in 2014 a Paddy Power press ad offering bets on the outcome of Oscar Pistorius's murder trial drew 5,525 complaints, at the time the most for any UK ad, and the Advertising Standards Authority banned it for trivialising a murder trial and the death of a woman. And provocation with no link to the product teaches people to remember the outrage rather than the brand; Dahl's team advised that shocking ads should show some benefit of using the product instead of using shock as an unrelated gimmick.
Fear vs shock
The two are often confused because many ads use both. The difference is in what does the work.
- Fear threatens the viewer: something bad could happen to you or someone you love, and here is how to stop it. Its power depends on the threat feeling real and the action feeling achievable. See fear appeal.
- Shock breaks a norm: it shows what advertising is not supposed to show. Its power depends on surprise, and it need not threaten the viewer at all, as with Benetton's newborn or Burger King's mouldy burger.
- Both together is common in road safety and health, where a graphic scene is disturbing to watch and frightening to imagine happening to you, as in TAC's Girlfriend.
In Dahl's experiments the shocking poster beat the fear poster on attention and memory, but the two did about equally well at getting students to pick up HIV information afterwards. Shock is better at getting noticed; whether people then act still depends on what the ad asks them to do.
Every ad here that uses shock and provocation38
2020s
-
2021The Lost Class
Tricks gun-rights figures into rehearsing a commencement speech for a school that does not exist, turning their own words into the message.
-
2020Moldy Whopper
Deliberately making its flagship burger look disgusting, furred with mould, breaks fast-food convention to force people to stop and look.
2010s
-
2019Back-to-School Essentials
A cheerful back-to-school haul video curdles item by item into a school shooting, turning a banal format against viewers' complacency.
-
2016Like My Addiction ("Louise Delage")
A reveal film races through an admired Instagrammer's whole feed, exposing that she was an alcoholic whose followers cheered her on without seeing it.
-
2016Meet Graham
Confronts viewers with an uncomfortably lifelike body with no neck, no protruding nose or ears and airbag-like sacs between the ribs.
-
2014Eyes on the Road
Jolts a relaxed cinema audience with a sudden crash during what looks like an ordinary pre-show ad.
-
2013Telekinetic Coffee Shop Surprise
Real coffee-shop customers recoil as a young woman appears to unleash telekinetic revenge, a staged public scare built to be shared.
-
2012Meet the Superhumans
Cuts without warning from training to a car crash, a warzone and a hospital, confronting viewers with the origins of disability before slamming back to sport.
-
2011Last Dictator Standing
Lampoons Mugabe and his fellow strongmen through lookalikes, a provocation risky enough to get the spot pulled from television after threats against staff.
-
2011Unhate
Montages of world leaders kissing their adversaries, one pulled almost immediately, deliberately provoke outrage and debate to get the message noticed.
-
Be stupid.Diesel2010
Be Stupid
Photographs of reckless, cheeky stunts and blunt manifestos deliberately court controversy, enough for some posters to be banned.
-
2010The American Takeover
Swaps the bar's familiar national-flag wrapper for the Stars and Stripes, deliberately provoking young Romanians into outrage.
2000s
-
2009COW ("Only Stwpd Cowz Txt N Drive")
Lingering shots of a girl's head hitting a window and a baby's blank stare are deliberately graphic, built to jolt young drivers.
-
2008Hotel 626
Secretly snapping visitors through their webcam and showing the picture back in a madman's lair deliberately unnerves them, turning their own devices into horror props.
-
2007Pinkie ("Speeding. No One Thinks Big of You.")
The crude small-penis gesture is deliberately provocative and draws complaints of sexism, which the advertising regulator dismisses.
-
2006Still Free (Air Force One)
Grainy footage appears to show hooded figures spraying graffiti on the presidential plane, a deliberate hoax designed to be argued over and provoke official denials.
-
2006Bonded by Blood
Grabs attention with a slightly macabre premise: each poster is printed with the squad's own sterilised blood.
-
2005Not Even Once ("Just Once")
Deliberately disturbing imagery is the whole strategy, so raw that officials ask for the spots to be kept off air until the evening.
-
Beach, Bar, PoolClub 18-302002
Beach, Bar, Pool
Saucy visual innuendo deliberately provokes, enough to draw a complaint that the ads were pornographic.
-
2000Body Bags
Young people heap body bags outside a tobacco company's headquarters, a confrontational spectacle designed to provoke rather than politely advise.
1990s
-
1999Bugger
Builds the punchline and tagline around a mildly rude word, a cheeky provocation that draws a record number of complaints.
-
New Labour, New DangerThe Conservative Party (UK)1996
New Labour, New Danger ("Demon Eyes")
Portraying the opposition leader as satanic is provocative enough for the advertising watchdog to ask that the image not be used again.
-
Hello Boys.Wonderbra (Playtex)1994
Hello Boys
The provocative image sparks lasting debate about empowerment versus objectification, generating far more free coverage than its media spend.
-
1992Orange Man ("You Know When You've Been Tango'd")
Deliberately breaks soft-drink conventions with a full face slap, provocative enough to spark a playground craze and force its withdrawal.
-
United Colors of Benetton.United Colors of Benetton1991
New Born Baby ("Giusy")
A blood-smeared newborn with the cord uncut, carrying only the brand's logo, deliberately tests what advertising is allowed to show.
1980s
-
1989Girlfriend ("If You Drink, Then Drive, You're a Bloody Idiot")
Filmed in a working emergency ward with a real medical crew, it lets the trauma unfold in order to upset, outrage and appal drink drivers.
-
1987Hitler
Dots slowly assemble a face while a voiceover praises a leader's achievements, then reveal it as Hitler's, a deliberately disturbing payoff.
-
1987The Grim Reaper
Deliberately horrifying imagery of people knocked down like pins forces attention onto the epidemic, at the cost of public outcry and deepening stigma.
-
1986Don't Die of Ignorance ("Monolith")
Puts apocalyptic imagery such as an exploding cliff face on television, deliberately terrifying a nation into reading a leaflet sent to every household.
-
1981Myriam ("Le 2 septembre, j'enlève le haut")
The striptease premise provokes feminist complaints, a court order and a televised debate, multiplying free coverage.
1970s
-
1973The 60-Year-Old Swede
The provocative claim embarrasses a nation so effectively that it sparks a debate in Parliament after only six airings.
-
Chi mi ama mi segua.Jesus Jeans (Maglificio Calzificio Torinese)1973
Chi mi ama mi segua ("He who loves me, follows me")
Laying a Gospel line across a close-up of a model's behind in tiny shorts deliberately courts accusations of blasphemy.
-
Would you be more careful if it was you that got pregnant?Health Education Council (UK)1970
Pregnant Man ("Would you be more careful if it was you that got pregnant?")
A heavily pregnant man is an image many find shocking, which is exactly what makes men stop and look.
1960s
1940s
-
I dreamed I went shopping in my Maidenform braMaidenform1949
I Dreamed I Went Shopping in My Maidenform Bra
Showing underwear in a public setting is risqué enough to draw complaints, which only helps the idea catch fire.
-
1942This Is Nazi Brutality
A hooded, chained victim and a bulletin announcing the execution of a whole village's men confront viewers with atrocity head-on.
-
1942Your Talk May Kill Your Comrades
Showing soldiers killed by their own side's gossip is, as the V&A says, unusually frank for a poster.
1910s
Questions people ask
What is shock advertising?
Shock advertising deliberately breaks a social norm, with graphic, sexual, religious or disgusting content, to startle people into attention and get them talking. The researchers Dahl, Frankenberger and Manchanda define it as a combination of norm violation and surprise.
What are the most controversial ads of all time?
Widely debated examples include Lyndon Johnson's "Daisy" (1964), Australia's "Grim Reaper" AIDS ad (1987), Benetton's campaigns by Oliviero Toscani such as "New Born Baby" (1991), Wonderbra's "Hello Boys" (1994) and Paddy Power's banned Oscar Pistorius ad (2014).
Does shock advertising work?
It reliably wins attention: in a 2003 study, a shocking poster drew more attention and better recall than fear or information posters. It can also offend, stigmatise or be banned, so it works best when the shock is tied to the message and the brand.
Which ad received the most complaints in the UK?
In 2014 a Paddy Power press ad offering bets on the outcome of Oscar Pistorius's murder trial drew 5,525 complaints, which the Advertising Standards Authority said made it the most complained-about ad it had ever handled. The ASA banned it for trivialising a murder trial and the death of a woman.
Why did Benetton use shocking ads?
In the 1980s and 1990s Benetton's art director, the photographer Oliviero Toscani, ran images of real life, from a newborn baby to prisoners on death row, often without showing any clothes. The Guardian's obituary of Toscani noted that the pictures provoked because they appeared in ad space, not because of what they showed.
What is the difference between shock and fear advertising?
Fear advertising threatens the viewer with a consequence and offers a way out. Shock advertising breaks a norm to surprise people, and need not threaten them at all; many public-health ads use both.
