Your Talk May Kill Your Comrades

War Office (UK)1942

Your Talk May Kill Your Comrades is a 1942 security poster for the Army (lithograph) for War Office, created by James Upton Ltd, Birmingham and London.

Abram Games's 1942 poster 'Your talk may kill your comrades': a spiral issuing from a soldier's mouth turns into a blade that pierces three soldiers in the foreground See the original
U.S. National Archives, via Wikimedia Commons — public domain

The line

Your talk may kill your comrades

Why it works

A soldier's head looms in the background, and from his open mouth a spiral uncoils into a long blade that runs straight through three soldiers in the foreground, above the words “Your talk may kill your comrades.” Abram Games designed it in 1942 for the War Office, and it was printed for H.M. Stationery Office by James Upton Ltd. Games was himself a serving soldier: the National Army Museum records that he was conscripted in 1940, posted to the War Office in 1941 to design posters for the Army, and in November 1942 made “Official War Poster Artist”, a title no other artist has held, producing more than 100 designs. The museum adds that the face at the centre is a self-portrait, and that while the civilian “Careless Talk Costs Lives” campaign used humour, this poster confronts soldiers directly with the result of loose talk. The Victoria and Albert Museum calls its depiction of the deaths of three comrades unusually frank. It is studied as a model of the method the National Army Museum credits to Games, getting maximum meaning from minimum means, with one graphic device carrying the whole argument.

Techniques

  • Visual metaphor Words literally become a weapon: the spiral of speech ends in a blade through three comrades.
  • Shock and provocation Showing soldiers killed by their own side's gossip is, as the V&A says, unusually frank for a poster.

Sources · 4

  1. Your Talk May Kill Your Comrades (Art.IWM PST 2869) Imperial War Museums · iwm.org.uk
  2. 'Your talk may kill your comrades', 1942 National Army Museum · collection.nam.ac.uk
  3. Abram Games and the power of the poster National Army Museum · nam.ac.uk
  4. Your talk may kill your comrades Victoria and Albert Museum · collections.vam.ac.uk

Updated