Often a Bridesmaid but Never a Bride

Listerine1925

Often a Bridesmaid but Never a Bride is a 1925 magazine advertisement for Listerine, created by Lambert & Feasley.

1925 Listerine advertisement "Often a Bridesmaid but never a Bride": a troubled young woman reads a wedding announcement beside the story of her halitosis, from Photoplay, July 1925 See the original
Photoplay, July 1925 (Pacific Film Archive copy), Media History Digital Library — public domain

The line

Often a bridesmaid but never a bride

Why it works

The ad that turned bad breath into a medical condition. Listerine had been sold for decades as a surgical antiseptic and all-purpose germicide when Gerard Lambert's team seized on a clinical-sounding word, halitosis, and rebuilt the brand's advertising around the fear of it. The most famous execution, credited to copywriters Milton Feasley and Gordon Seagrove, told the "pathetic" case of Edna, nearing thirty and "often a bridesmaid but never a bride," undone by a problem even her closest friends would not mention. It is studied as the archetype of the 1920s melodrama of social shame, which historian Roland Marchand credited with founding a whole school of advertising practice: sell the problem first, then the cure. The commercial effect was enormous. Lambert's yearly earnings climbed from about $115,000 in 1922 to more than $8 million by 1929, and the ad immortalized its headline as an everyday phrase. Ad Age ranked the campaign No. 48 of the 20th century.

Techniques

  • Fear appeal A clinical-sounding condition, halitosis, is presented as a hidden social danger that can quietly ruin a woman's chances of marriage.
  • Storytelling The sad tale of Edna, nearing thirty and never a bride, dramatises the problem before the cure is offered.

Sources · 4

  1. A Fresh Breath Chemical Heritage Foundation (now Science History Institute), archived copy via Internet Archive · web.archive.org
  2. Exploring U.S. History: Understanding Advertising Roy Rosenzweig Center for History and New Media, George Mason University · chnm.gmu.edu
  3. What Is Advertising? William M. O'Barr, Advertising & Society Review (Project MUSE) (2005) · muse.jhu.edu
  4. Ad Age Advertising Century: Top 100 Advertising Campaigns Ad Age (1999), archived copy via Internet Archive · web.archive.org

Updated