That Liberty Shall Not Perish from the Earth

Fourth Liberty Loan (U.S. Treasury)1918

That Liberty Shall Not Perish from the Earth is a 1918 liberty Loan poster (colour lithograph) for Fourth Liberty Loan, created by Ketterlinus, Philadelphia.

Joseph Pennell's 1918 Liberty Loan poster: the Statue of Liberty with her head and torch blown away stands in New York harbour while the Manhattan skyline burns and aircraft fly overhead; text 'That liberty shall not perish from the earth – Buy Liberty Bonds – Fourth Liberty Loan' See the original
Library of Congress, via Wikimedia Commons — public domain

The line

That liberty shall not perish from the earth – Buy Liberty Bonds – Fourth Liberty Loan

Why it works

A Fourth Liberty Loan poster of 1918 that imagines New York under attack: the Statue of Liberty stands with her head and torch shot away, the city burns behind her and enemy aircraft fill the sky. Joseph Pennell, an associate chairman of the Committee on Public Information's Division of Pictorial Publicity, noted the idea in his sketchbook on the train home from a meeting about a poster competition for the loan; he later described it as 'New York City bombed, shot down, burning blown up by an enemy'. The Rockwell Center for American Visual Studies notes that it was printed in red and purple on yellow paper and that its title rewrites the last line of Lincoln's Gettysburg Address, putting liberty where Lincoln had put government. The loan was open from 28 September to 19 October 1918. Pennell published a book on the poster the same year, subtitled 'a text-book for artists and amateurs, governments and teachers and printers', and the Library of Congress holds his watercolour study as well as the printed sheet. It is studied because it pictures an attack that could not yet happen, since aircraft could not then cross the Atlantic, and makes that imagined loss the reason to buy bonds.

Techniques

  • Fear appeal Shows New York in flames and Liberty beheaded, so the reader pictures the war arriving at home unless bonds are bought.
  • Transfer Borrows the authority of Lincoln's Gettysburg Address and the Statue of Liberty for a bond drive.
  • Visual metaphor The broken statue stands for American freedom itself being destroyed.

Sources · 2

  1. That liberty shall not perish from the earth - Buy liberty bonds Fourth Liberty Loan / Joseph Pennell del. ; Ketterlinus Phila. imp. (catalogue record) Library of Congress · loc.gov
  2. That Liberty Shall Not Perish From the Earth Rockwell Center for American Visual Studies (2011) · rockwellcenter.org

Updated