Guide

How to analyse an advert

To analyse an advert, establish its context and audience, describe what it shows and says, identify its message, appeals and techniques, then judge its effect with evidence. Here is a six-step method, worked through on Volkswagen’s “Think Small”.

Updated 6 November 20267 min read

An advert analysis answers three questions: what is the ad trying to make its audience think, feel or do, how does it go about it, and does it work? The six steps below take you there. They suit a poster, a print ad, a television commercial or a social film, and they follow the approach writing centres such as Purdue OWL recommend for visual texts: start with the rhetorical situation, meaning the author, the audience, the purpose and the context, then look closely at the evidence on the page or screen.

Step 1: Context and audience

Before looking at the detail, establish the facts around the ad. Who made it: which brand or organisation, and which agency? When and where did it run: in which country, publication, channel or platform? Who was it aimed at, and what did that audience already think about the product? What was happening in the market, or in the world, at the time? Context explains choices that otherwise look odd, and the audience tells you what the ad had to overcome.

Step 2: What you see and hear

Describe the ad as if to someone who cannot see it. For print and posters: the image, the layout, the empty space, the colours, the type, and where your eye goes first. For film: the setting, the casting, the shots, the edit, the music and sound, and what happens in what order. Note what is missing, too: an absent product, price or logo is a choice. Analysis depends on accurate description, so be specific.

Step 3: The message and the line

State the message in one sentence: what the advertiser wants the audience to believe. Then find the words that carry it, usually the headline, the slogan or the end line, and look at how they are written: their length, rhythm and tone, any double meaning, and how they work with the picture. Ask whether the message is stated outright or left for the audience to work out.

Step 4: The appeals and techniques

Identify how the ad persuades. Start with the three classical appeals: ethos (why should I trust the speaker?), pathos (what am I meant to feel?) and logos (what reason or proof am I given?), and decide which one carries most weight. Then name the more specific techniques, such as humour, demonstration, storytelling, testimonial, comparison or card stacking. The full list is on the advertising techniques page.

Step 5: The psychology

Ask why the techniques work on people. Advertising relies on well-studied habits of mind: we notice what stands out from its surroundings (the isolation effect), we warm to people who admit a flaw (the pratfall effect), we follow what others do (social proof) and we defer to experts (authority). Naming the principle turns a description into an explanation. The psychology pages list each principle with the ads that use it.

Step 6: The effect and the evidence

Finally, judge whether the ad worked, using evidence rather than opinion. Look for sales or market share, research results, awards, press coverage at the time, how long the campaign ran, and whether its line entered everyday speech. Separate the ad’s effect from other causes, such as price, distribution or the news. Then consider effects the advertiser may not have intended, including criticism, and how the ad reads today.

Worked example: Volkswagen, “Think Small” (1959)

1. Context and audience

Think Small was made by Doyle Dane Bernbach (DDB) in New York for Volkswagen of America in 1959, with copy by Julian Koenig and art direction by Helmut Krone. In his history The Real Mad Men, Andrew Cracknell describes the task as selling a small, basic, foreign car to a market in love with huge, chrome-finned American cars. The car also came from America’s wartime enemy, and some at the agency objected; George Lois remembered the job as selling “a Nazi car in a Jewish town”. The budget, $600,000, was about 2% of what Detroit was prepared to spend on its new compact cars. The account team had found that Beetle owners often had to justify their choice to other people, so the ads set out to give them arguments.

2. What you see

Most of the page is white space. A small black-and-white photograph of the Beetle sits at a slight angle in the top left-hand corner, and the headline, “Think small.”, and short columns of copy sit well below it. Next to the flamboyant Detroit car ads of the 1950s, the restraint is the first thing a reader notices.

3. The message and the line

The message is that a small car is the smart choice. “Think small.” is an instruction that turns the market’s values upside down: in a country that prized size, it makes smallness sound like a decision a clever person would make. The copy opens by admitting the car is no longer much of a novelty, and that nobody even stares at its shape any more, then turns to what smallness saves: 32 miles to the gallon, five pints of oil instead of five quarts, and no need for anti-freeze.

4. The appeals and techniques

  • Ethos carries the most weight. By admitting that the car is small and odd, the ad earns belief for everything else it says. Krone summed up the approach as “a little admission gains a great acceptance”.
  • Logos supplies the reasons: fuel, oil and running costs, each a fact a buyer could check.
  • Pathos is light but present in the wit. Ad Age observed that the tone set the car apart for people who thought themselves immune to the hidden persuaders, and the joke flatters that reader.
  • The techniques are humour and card stacking: the car’s apparent weaknesses are reframed as reasons to buy.

5. The psychology

Two principles explain much of its power. The isolation effect: a tiny car alone in white space stands out on pages crowded with other advertising. The pratfall effect: a source that admits a flaw becomes more likeable and more believable.

6. The effect and the evidence

Volkswagen sold 185,000 cars in the US in 1960, 23% more than the year before, according to Hagerty, and US Beetle sales reached a record 570,000 a year in 1970. In 1999 Ad Age ranked DDB’s Volkswagen work No. 1 of the top 100 advertising campaigns of the twentieth century. A careful analysis adds a caveat: sales were already climbing before any advertising began, from around 2,000 cars in 1953 to more than 150,000 by 1958, on the strength of a growing dealer network. The campaign built on demand as well as creating it.

Printable checklist

  • Who made the ad, when, where and for whom?
  • What did the audience think about the product or issue before seeing it?
  • What exactly do you see and hear, and what is left out?
  • Where does your eye go first, and why?
  • What is the message, in one sentence?
  • What is the headline, slogan or end line, and how is it written?
  • Why should the audience trust the speaker? (ethos)
  • What is the audience meant to feel? (pathos)
  • What reason or proof is given? (logos)
  • Why this moment and this place? (kairos)
  • Which techniques are used, and which matters most?
  • Which psychological principle explains why it works?
  • What evidence shows whether it worked?
  • What else might explain the result?
  • How does the ad read today, and has any of it aged badly?

Turning your analysis into an essay paragraph

An analysis becomes an essay when every observation serves an argument. Build each paragraph in three moves: a claim about how the ad persuades, evidence from the ad itself, and the effect on the audience. Keep description short; the marks are in explaining why a choice matters.

Here is an example paragraph on “Think Small”:

Volkswagen’s 1959 “Think Small” advert persuades mainly through ethos, winning trust by admitting what other car makers hid. The small black-and-white photograph of the Beetle, alone in a corner of an almost empty page, concedes at once that the car is tiny, and the copy goes further, joking that nobody even stares at its shape any more. Having been honest about its weakness, the advert is believed when it lists its strengths: the mileage, the oil, the running costs. For an American audience used to boastful car advertising, the candour itself became the reason to trust the brand, and “small” changed from a fault into a sensible choice.

To go further, compare the ad with others from the same period, or with a later ad that borrows its approach, such as DDB’s campaign for Avis, which turned being No. 2 into the reason to choose it.

Questions people ask

How do you analyse an advert?

Work through six steps: establish the context and audience, describe what you see and hear, state the message and examine the line, identify the appeals and techniques, explain the psychology behind them, and judge the effect with evidence such as sales, research or awards.

What should I look for when analysing an advertisement?

Look at who made it and for whom; the image, layout, colour, type, music and casting; the headline or slogan; the appeals to credibility, emotion and reason; and any evidence of what the ad achieved.

How do you analyse ethos, pathos and logos in an ad?

Ask three questions: why should the audience trust the speaker (ethos), what are they meant to feel (pathos), and what reason or proof are they given (logos). Then decide which appeal carries most weight by imagining the ad without each one.

How do you write an advert analysis essay?

Open with a thesis about how the ad persuades its audience, then write paragraphs that each make one claim, support it with specific evidence from the ad, and explain its effect on the audience. Keep description brief and end with a judgement on how well the ad works.

What is a good advert to analyse?

Choose an ad with a clear audience, a strong idea and well-documented results. Volkswagen’s “Think Small” (1959) is a common choice because its context, layout and appeals are easy to discuss and its success is well recorded.

Is it “analyse” or “analyze”?

Both are correct: “analyse” is the British spelling and “analyze” the North American spelling of the same word.

Sources8

  1. Elements of Analysis (Visual Rhetoric: Analyzing Visual Documents) Purdue OWL · owl.purdue.edu
  2. Excerpt: Think Small, Basic, Ugly, Economical, and Foreign (from Andrew Cracknell, The Real Mad Men) Publishers Weekly (2012) · publishersweekly.com
  3. Tall Tale for Small Car (Steven Heller interviews Dominik Imseng) PRINT (2016) · printmag.com
  4. Volkswagen crisis: brand that invented modern advertising is dented The Conversation (2015) · theconversation.com
  5. Watershed VW campaign turns 50 Hagerty (2009) · hagerty.com
  6. How Brands Really Grow 5: Shaping What People Want (Jan Hofmeyr, Kantar TNS) GreenBook (2015) · greenbook.org
  7. Ad Age Advertising Century: Top 100 Advertising Campaigns Ad Age (1999), via Internet Archive · web.archive.org
  8. Analyse Oxford Learner’s Dictionaries · oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com
  • Ethos, pathos and logos in advertising

    Ethos, pathos and logos are the three rhetorical appeals: persuasion through the speaker’s credibility, the audience’s emotions and the argument itself. Here is what each means, with real ads that use them and a checklist for spotting them.

    5 min read

  • The 7 propaganda techniques, with examples from real ads

    The seven propaganda techniques are name-calling, glittering generalities, transfer, testimonial, plain folks, card stacking and bandwagon, listed by the Institute for Propaganda Analysis in 1937. Here is each one, with real ads.

    6 min read

  • What is a slogan? Examples, and what makes one work

    A slogan is a short, memorable phrase that a brand, campaign or cause repeats to sum up what it stands for, such as Nike’s “Just Do It.” Here is how slogans differ from taglines and jingles, where the word comes from, and what the lasting ones share.

    6 min read